Royals Review: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:





Remembering Emil Brown

While the close of the Mike Sweeney Era has understandably received the most attention, the 2008 campaign will also be the first since 2005 which won't include the vaguely adequate production and braggadocio of Emil Brown. While the end of Emil's time in Kansas City has been long established, (and debated, thanks to a flurry of interest generated by Poz) there's something appropriate about returning to it now, during Spring Training, considering that Emil was that rarest of creatures: the man who makes the team in March.

A Chicago native, Emil was drafted in 1994 by Oakland, and ended up joining the Pirates as a Rule Five draftee in 1996. Brown broke camp with the Pirates in 1997, and while he never stuck as a regular, he spent the entire season getting a big league per diem. Brown hit only .179/.304/.284 in 66 games that year, and aside from a bizarre four day stretch in which he hit his first two big league homers of Terry Mulholland, then with the Cubs, little of note occurred. Although his season was lame and unremarkable, according to some insiders, his infectious attitude and brio helped inspire his teammates to a 79-83 record, the last time the Pirates were sorta OK.

Brown returned mostly to the minor leagues in 1998-9, appearing in only 19 games total as a Pirate. In 2000 however, Emil was called back up for short stints in May, June and July, before getting an extended look in August and September. Brown was 25 then, and this was his time to prove himself. Instead, he began his callup with an 0-8 in a doubleheader against the Dodgers, and ultimately hit .204/.288/.280 in 39 games and 101 PAs with the Pirates. Undeterred, the Pirates gave him one last start, as he again headed north with the Bucs in 2001, serving as the team's primary center fielder until July 1, when he was traded to the Padres. At the time of the trade, he was hitting just .203/.300/.325. Emil was consistent as a Pirate: he never hit. With the '01 Padres Brown didn't do much better, hitting .071/.133/.071, almost exclusively as a pinch hitter.

At the end of his age 26 season, Brown was the owner of a career .200/.289/.302 line in 457 scattered PAs. Essentially, he was fully blossoming into a tweener, only, tweeners are supposed to hit better than that. For the next three years, Brown bounced from the Tampa Bay, Cincinnati, St. Louis and Houston organizations. While he hit decently in 2002-3, in early 2004 he was terrible, hitting .281/.339/.333 in Memphis and was released by the Cardinals. In August, he was signed by the Astros, and he responded with a .337/.365/.533 line in 26 games with New Orleans. That hot streak likely earned him another contract with the Royals, and was the beginning of his emergence, at age 30, as a Major leaguer.

Against very weak competition, Brown emerged during Spring Training 2005 as the strongest candidate for the right field job thanks to an inspired March. Brown, hit .389 in 26 games that spring, belting five homers for good measure. Brown was not the Opening Day starter, that ceremonial honor went to Matt Stairs, but he did start in game two, and essentially remained an everyday player for the next three seasons.

Interestingly, Brown's hot March - a stretch that likely saved his career and earned him millions of dollars - did not translate into a hot April and May. He hit .161/.254/.339 during his first eighteen games with the Royals, a level of performance which would have landed back on the journeyman AAA player fun bus had he done so the month before. Brown responded with a strong May however, settling in as a regular with a .313/.389/.506 line. In June, he got even hotter, hitting .366/.412/.527. On July 1, 2005, he was hitting .297/.365/.474 and had been the cleanup hitter for a big league team for two solid months. After his two month tear, Brown would never hit at such a high level, for so long, again as a Royal. He would have two similar months in 2006, but they were not consecutive. From July 1 until the end of the season, Brown hit .278/.336/.441, and finished the year with a .286/.349/.455 line in 144 starts and 150 games total. His 86 RsBI would lead the team, and he would finish second on the club with 17 home runs. This was all acceptable enough, one would suppose, but hardly something truly valuable. Brown had his merits. He was cheap, and for a mid-decade Royal, Brown was insanely patient, which along with a solid batting average made him productive. Despite being a large man however, Emil was never a true power hitter. In 2005, Mike Sweeney, despite playing in 28 fewer games, managed more homers (21 to 17) and more doubles (39 to 31) than Emil.

Either happy with Emil's generic production or dissatisfied with any better options, Allard firmly ensconced Emil as the regular left fielder in 2006, switching sides to accommodate Reggie Sanders. Ironically, Brown had a terrible Spring Training this time around, hitting .211. (If Brown was one of the game's designated bad men, this is where you'd insert something snarky about his sense of entitlement or laziness or whatever. But, he's not, for whatever reason, so no biggie.) As he had done in 2005, Brown crawled out of the gate, hitting .227/.315/.333 in April. By May, he was Emil Brown again, which is to say he was Ken Harvey was less doubles and a little bit more power. In June of 2006 he had one of his two remaining good months as a Royal, hitting .329/.385/.506. Specifically, from June 2-27, he hit .338/.391/.532, helping the Royals win nine of eleven games, mostly against the National League. Again, although I was never quite cognizant of it at the time, with Emil, it was really always about batting average. When he hit .360 on balls in play from time to time, he was a dangerous hitter. Throughout his Royal tenure, he never really had a power surge. He had singles surges. In 2006 he mixed in some doubles power, but that was it. Despite certain physical and career similarities to someone like Jack Cust, Emil really wasn't your typical AAAA journeyman with under-appreciated secondary skills. Not surprisingly, the singles and the RsBI kept Emil in the good graces of many.

Brown cooled off in July, as his monthly BA dropped to .270. In August, at the age of 31, Emil put together one final, sustained, hot streak as a Royal, hitting .327/.382/.571. His best slugging month ever, Emil hit five homers that August, and added nine doubles, also a large total for him. However, once again, he cooled off again in September, and finished the year with a .287/.358/.457 line. Cumulatively, his rate stats were just slightly better, but thanks to a few weeks missed due to small injuries, his season totals dropped a wee little smidgen. He ended up with 15 HRs and 81 RsBI. Only the power hitting alien that invaded Mark Teahen's body in 2006 prevent Emil from proudly leading the team in those two categories that year. Considering that Emil made $1.7 million in 2006 (thank you zombie service time from the late 1990s!) he was slowly sliding from cool story to just another unlovable player on a bad team.

Still, in 2006, perhaps inspired by Teahen, Emil managed 41 doubles, which was actually 9th best in the AL that season, a nice accomplishment, even given the inherent weirdness of the doubles leaderboard each year. (Fast guys, singles hitters, and dudes who play in Fenway a lot, rinse, repeat.) After another generic Spring Training in which he hit .267 (insert second snarky remark about Emil's lack of motivation and focus), Emil once again hit terribly in April, coughing up a .186/.237/.229 line. Unfortunately, after a third straight cold start, Emil didn't turn up the heat in May. Well, we'll all remember his one homer that month, a blast in game 43 at Coors Field (this was before God made the Rockies win), and more astute fans may even be able to recall his lone double that month as well. All told, he hit .218/.283/.327 in May. Through May 30th Emil was hitting .200/.257/.272, and competing with, sadly, a whole host of Royals for the title of Worst Hitter in the American League. He had one home run, one triple and four doubles.

With the change of the calendar, Emil celebrated June with a two-hit game, double-included game over those stingy Devil Rays hurlers. The rest of the way, that is to say, over the next 75 games and 261 PAs, Emil hit .286/.322/.386 and finished the year with a .257/.300/.347 line. Returning to the numbers behind his mini-resurgence over the final four months of the season, it's clear enough that something had changed. Even when he got his batting average back he'd lost nearly half his walks and almost all of his power. As part of the team's miracle run at a remarkably low HR total, Emil managed only six bombs, and just 13 doubles. After paying Brown over $3.3 million to be a slower Shane Costa, Dayton Moore elected not to bring him back for 2008, a decision he has been unable to reach with similarly uninspiring players such as Ross Gload and Mark Grudzielanek.

Of course, no mention of Emil's 2007 season would be complete without reference to the embarrassing and infantile pellet gun incident, which occurred on July 27th. While she was standing near Pena's locker, Karen Kornacki was hit "near the eye" with a pellet fired from a plastic gun by Emil. Amazingly, a man who was born in 1974 had a pellet gun on his person. A man born in 1974, who is a millionaire, no less. After being a curious news item for a few days, the story quickly faded away, apparently just a weird and funny accident.

Coupled with the loss of Sweeney, the 2008 season should be especially heart-wrenching for Royals fans given Brown's historical legacy with the team. Emil ranks 37th in team history in hits (401, two behind Ibanez), 29th in doubles (85) and 34th in home runs. In spite of being both a silly and overrated statistic, Emil was a prolific RBI man, by the horrible standards of his franchise, and leaves as the 29th highest RBIer in team history, sandwiched between Angel Berroa and U.L. Washington. When DeJesus drives in his 21st man in 2008, we can only hope that the team honors him with an in-game ceremony, for at that moment, he will have eclipsed Emil.

Looking back, what stands out is how very fortunate Emil has been to even scratch out the modest career he's had. In 2004, he hit rock bottom when he was released by the Cardinals. Then, after getting another chance with the Astros, he turned in his best minor league mini-season ever, which earned him a throwaway Spring Training invite with the Royals. Blessed by the Royals' inability to produce young talent, even at the simplest of positions to fill, Brown had a rare chance to make the team, and he responded, with a you-can't-ignore-this Spring Training. Then, again saved by the lack of options around him, the team stuck with him two more times, after a slow 2005 start, and an OK but not great overall 2005 season.  In January, the A's signed Brown to a $1.4 million dollar contract, which will be the third largest payday of his career. While he will never be fabulously wealthy, his good fortune/hot hitting against AAA pitchers in 2004 and Spring Training flotsam in 2005 has meant that he can retire from the game, whenever, in financial comfort. In line to earn over six million dollars between 2006-08, Emil has crossed the threshold between having to, proverbially, sell insurance, and being able to live in self-employed comfort. Just three years ago, that seemed very very unlikely. Barely more likely, in fact, than say, me being able to do so.

Congratulations Emil. I hope you appreciate your good fortune.    

0 recs | Comment 24 comments

Read Related

Story-email Email | Print |

Comments

Display:

for others it leaves
nothing to be said
Hillman, you're on notice.

by FireBell on Mar 4, 2008 11:41 AM EST   0 recs

Whenever you think of league average
think of Emil Brown 2005-06

League Average LF:  .282/.354/.458
(park adjusted)

Emil Brown 2005:    .286/.349/.455

Emil Brown 2005:    .287/.358/.457

by Gopherballs on Mar 4, 2008 12:05 PM EST   0 recs

Emil nearly made the Cards
He had a great spring training in 2004 with the Cards:

"Emil played so well ... A guy who hits and play defense like he did, and then I tell him he's not going to go to the big leagues, that's pretty tough. He has big-league ability and he played like a big-leaguer, so why isn't he in the big leagues?"
-Tony LaRussa, on making Emil one of the final cuts

It wasn't that long ago, but I'm really puzzled as to why the Royals settled on Emil as their starting outfielder. It wasn't like he got hot and forced their hand. He was on the All-Star ballot in 2005 for Pete's sake. They were pretty much saying "yep, this 30 year old outfielder with a lifetime batting average of .200 in 457 MLB PAs and an OPS of .591 is going to be our starting right fielder"

By the way, here are the Royals on the 2005 All-Star Ballot:

C John Buck
1B Mike Sweeney
2B Ruben Gotay
3B Mark Teahen
SS Angel Berroa
LF Eli Marrero
CF David DeJesus
RF Emil Brown
DH Calvin Pickering

This was the team they thought they would have. Its amazing they even won 56 games.

Relive Royals History at royalsretro.blogspot.com

by RoyalsRetro on Mar 4, 2008 12:11 PM EST   0 recs

Aha
Guys vying for outfield spots in the spring of 2005:

David DeJesus
Eli Marrero
Emil Brown
Matt Stairs
Abraham Nunez
Aaron Guiel
Abarham Nunez
Matt Diaz

Really? Allard couldn't find any better outfielders on the market than this?

Relive Royals History at royalsretro.blogspot.com

by RoyalsRetro on Mar 4, 2008 12:13 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

Great decisions
Matt Diaz
Aaron Guiel
should have been the starters.  Guiel was huge in Japan this year (who isn't?).  Diaz is hitting .330 every year.

by David Howards Legacy on Mar 4, 2008 12:35 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

but when we find out he's the 25th
best royal ever...
Hillman, you're on notice.

by FireBell on Mar 4, 2008 12:13 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

I have a hard time believing TLR there
the Cards still had a pretty stacked lineup in 2004, and given his need for a 3rd lefty specialist or another utility guy or seven, i doubt Emil had much of a chance

by royalsreview on Mar 4, 2008 12:52 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

What about his bizarre quotes?
Wasn't he on record as saying he could play like Vlad and Manny but just wasn't getting the respect or recognition, or something insane like that one year?

by royalblues on Mar 4, 2008 12:51 PM EST   0 recs

yea...
if anyone can dig up that old story, that'd be great, i couldn't hunt it down

by royalsreview on Mar 4, 2008 12:54 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

Vlademil!
"I'm tired of all these stupid a$$ questions every day. Why the f**k would I hit Brett for Miller?" The rest is history.

by DC Royal on Mar 4, 2008 1:55 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

NATIONWIDE!

by loyal2s dad on Mar 4, 2008 12:59 PM EST   0 recs

I hope he saved his money
He's had a few years now where he's made millions and those will be the only years in his career where he makes anywhere near that.  If managed correctly, he could live comfortably on that money for the rest of his life.  Unfortunately, I have the sneaking suspicion that Emil really thinks he is a great baseball player who was just going to get better and better, making more money every year, therefore he could afford to spend away his salary every year.  I hope not.
I probably disagree with you.

by NYRoyal on Mar 4, 2008 1:11 PM EST   0 recs

Sadly, as Emil goes,
so go the majority of the players that break on the scene late. The problem with finally making it after being a journeyman is that you may have already played part of your prime in the minors. See also: Brady Clark.

Still, if Brown invested wisely, he's still set for life. And the A's signed him for some unknown reason.

A mind without purpose will walk in dark places.

by NHZ on Mar 4, 2008 1:23 PM EST   0 recs

He has some value
He can hit lefties. Defensive metrics for whatever reason always rank him highly. So long as he isn't exposed as an everyday outfielder, he probably has some utility as a fourth outfielder.
Relive Royals History at royalsretro.blogspot.com

by RoyalsRetro on Mar 4, 2008 1:29 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

yes
weird contract

maybe he is decent in the OF

by royalsreview on Mar 4, 2008 1:30 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

Retro hit on something there:
I'm refering to the demise of the platoon in MLB. Looking back at that 2005 OF situation, a platoon with Guiel and either Brown or Diaz would have made a lot of sense.

Alas, with the advent of pitch counts and situational relievers, came the birth of the 11 and 12 man pitching staffs. This, along with the DH spot, has rendered old-fashioned platoons virtually obsolete.

by loyal2s dad on Mar 4, 2008 2:11 PM EST   0 recs

Not that I want to bring it up
But I will anyway. Why did we have people pulling for Emil over Guillen this offseason? Honestly, money aside, where is the argument for Emil?

by MileHighKCfan on Mar 4, 2008 2:57 PM EST   0 recs

not sure either
I'm pretty convinced JoePo was just pulling our leg with all his Brown stuff.

The thing is, Guillen is much close to being Emil than being Manny Ramirez, and I think people are pushing back against the idea that he's solved any real problems. He's also been flagged in various ways, fairly or not, as an unlikeable guy.

Not that Emil was very personable either. But alas...

by royalsreview on Mar 4, 2008 3:37 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

Vs. Lefties
2005 .313/.368/.538
2006 .236/.316.465
2007 .317
.375/.448

Pair him up with a lefty that can hit righties, someone like Cliff Floyd and you may have a decent, low-cost platoon.

Not saying I wish the Royals had done this, but I can see the argument.

Relive Royals History at royalsretro.blogspot.com

by RoyalsRetro on Mar 4, 2008 4:00 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

The problem is that Emil is deteriorating
I think Emil has followed the development curve to the point where he's dropped off of the deterioration cliff.  His skills really dropped off last season.  I see more deterioration coming.  I would guess that against lefties this year he'll hit something like .330/.340/.420.  That isn't even good for the lesser part of a platoon.
I probably disagree with you.

by NYRoyal on Mar 4, 2008 5:52 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

typo
That was supposed to be .300/.340/.420.
I probably disagree with you.

by NYRoyal on Mar 4, 2008 5:53 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

theres really no reason to pay for that
"So whattya say, should we clean this place up?" - Tom Cruise

by DyeFan187 on Mar 4, 2008 6:47 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

And even if he played for free...
...there would be no reason to waste a roster spot on him.  Unfortunately there will only be 4 bench spots and Gathright and German are out of options.  I'd rather see what Gathright can do than waste a roster spot on a declining player who will have no part of the Royals future and likely no trade value.

That's why it was great that Moore non-tendered Brown, despite the fact that Dutton and Kaegel thought for some odd reason that re-signing him was a lock.

I probably disagree with you.

by NYRoyal on Mar 4, 2008 7:20 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

great column
but, I wonder when I see how much effort you put into it if it might be dissertation avoidance...
just speaking from experience
Success is counted sweetest by those who ne'er succeed. - Emily Dickinson

by buddyball on Mar 4, 2008 7:59 PM EST   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about Kansas City Royals.
Ad-medium-smq

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
25ish percent progress report
Small
Greinke and the Brain Theme Song
100_1513_small
Of Brett Tomko and #5 Starters
100_1513_small
DICE v2.01
Nyroyal3a_small
Royals Confidence Index - Early May results

Recent FanPosts

Foccs_small
Player Performance Ed. 3 Final Results
Small
The Player I would like to get
Royalsretro_small
The 100 Greatest Royals of All-Time - #55 Tim Belcher
Img_2253_small
BOD: Boyfriend of the Day May 14, 2008 & May 15, 2008
Small
Cortes returns
Small
Can anyone say Mike Aviles?!?
Royalsreview_small
The Office -- Season Finale -- Open Thread
Hannibal_small
Kyle Davies?

Post New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Ad-banner-faketeams
Site Meter