Royals Review: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



New Blog: Five For Howling - for Coyotes fans Bar-right-arrows



The Top Ten Greatest Kansas City Athletics of All-Time

The Royals are on a three game road trip to play the Athletics in Oakland. That team used to be our team. Charlie Finley, Reggie Jackson, Catfish Hunter, Sal Bando, Joe Rudi. Those guys got their start here, in Kansas City.

I wish I knew more about the Kansas City Athletics. There doesn't seem to be an abundance of information out there on them. But they were a big part of Kansas City sports history, a team that floundered in Kansas City for over a decade. It was our first shot at Major League sports, and many fans have fond memories of the Athletics, despite their awful play.

For whatever reason, the A's get overlooked in Kansas City now. Perhaps because they were awful, perhaps because they last played at 22nd and Brooklyn over forty years ago, or perhaps they never felt like "our team" the way the Royals, founded by Kansas City native Ewing Kauffman, feel like "our team." The A's were transients, moving from Philadelphia, spending a decade in Kansas City as a rest stop before moving further west to Oakland.

In any case, the A's did happen, and we should pay them their proper respects. The Northern League Kansas City T-Bones will honor the Kansas City Athletics on August 16. There is also apparently a PBS documentary in the works, which I am eagerly anticipating.

There have been many great names in Kansas City Athletics history. Al Pilarcik. John Tsitouris. Ray Jablonski. Vern Handrahan. Joe Pignatano. Aurelio Monteagudo. Not great players, but great names nonetheless. Kansas City was the home of three Hall of Famers - Enos Slaughter, Reggie Jackson and Catfish Hunter. Roger Maris played for the Athletics before breaking the home run record. Kansas City was also a great breeding ground for future managers - Billy Martin, Dick Williams, Dick Howser, Whitey Herzog and Tony LaRussa.

But who were the great Kansas City Athletics? Let's take a brief look at the ten greatest Kansas City Athletics, based on Win Shares.

10. John Wyatt (tied) 1961-1966
292 games 27-28 3.74 ERA 73 saves

Wyatt was a right-handed closer in an era where relievers were starting to be used in "save" situations. He collected 73 saves in just over four seasons in Kansas City before being dealt to Boston. He played in the waning days of the Negro Leagues with Indianapolis and signed with the A's as a 21 year old. I guess its kind of surprising to know the Negro Leagues continued well after Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier. It lasted well into the 1950s, struggling as more and more African-American players integrated Major League Baseball.

Wyatt was a solid reliever in Kansas City, enjoying his best year in 1964 when he led the league in appearances and was named to his only All-Star game. From 1962-1965, only four pitchers collected more saves than Wyatt - this despite the fact Wyatt's teams never won more than 73 games.



10. Ray Herbert (tied) 1955-1961
152 games 37-48 4.25 ERA 32 complete games
40 Win Shares

Herbert had been a pretty awful starter in over 200 innings, posting a 5.08 ERA with is hometown Tigers when the A's purchased him in 1955. He was awful in his first season in KC, posting a 6.26 ERA, but was excellent the next two seasons. Like David Cone and John Smoltz, he was determined to curse the hometown team that dealt him.

In 1960, Herbert finished in the top ten in the league in wins and ERA. After a terrible start in 1961, the A's dealt him to the White Sox in a seven player deal for former 18 game winner Bob Shaw. Shaw would win nine games in KC before being dealt again, while Herbert would win 20 games the next season in Chicago.

9. Bill Tuttle 1958-1961
450 Games .261/.342/.369
42 Win Shares

The A's acquired Tuttle from Detroit in a thirteen player deal. How come trades were so much larger back then? Less salary complications? No worries about impending free agency?

Tuttle was a centerfielder known for his defense who could draw a walk, but didn't hit for much power or average. He hit .231 in his first year in Kansas City, but rebounded to hit .300 the next year and earn MVP votes. He would slump to .256 in 1960, and in 1961, the A's dealt him to Minnesota. Tuttle was often seen on the field with a huge wad of tobacco in his mouth, but later in life his face would be disfigured by oral cancer, leading him to be a passionate advocate against chewing tobacco.

 


8. Dick Green 1963-1967
538 games .239/.296/.359
45 Win Shares

Green was signed by the A's out of Iowa and by the age of 23, he was their every day second baseman. He slammed 26 home runs his first two seasons with the A's, but never hit above .264 in his four seasons in Kansas City. He was a bit of a free swinger as well, striking out 110 times in 1965, the eighth most in the league. He would hit just .198 in 1967, the last season the A's would spend in Kansas City. Green would spend eleven seasons in the big leagues, all with the A's, and would be part of three World Series teams in Oakland.

Just our luck. The A's never win more than 73 games in twelve years in Kansas City. Their first year in Oakland was their first winning season since 1952. Two years later, they won 100 games. The year after that, they were World Champs. That should have been our championship parade.

7. Hector Lopez 1955-1959
586 games .278/.337/.433
51 Win Shares

Lopez was the second Panamanian ever to play Major League Baseball and was considered a national hero. He was a solid third baseman and second baseman for four and a half seasons for the Athletics before spending seven years as a fourth outfielder for the Yankees. He hit .290 with fifteen home runs his rookie season, then followed that up with an eighteen home run season. In 1958, he hit three home runs in a game against the Senators. He has the fourth most home runs and RBI in Kansas City Athletics history. In 1959, he was dealt with future twenty-game winner Ralph Terry in a five player deal that raised red flags as to how serious the A's were about winning, and how serious they were about making the Yankees winners.

After his career, Lopez became the first black manager to reach the AAA level when he managed the Buffalo Bisons in 1969.

 


6. Bob Cerv 1957-1960
413 games .288/.342/.509
54 Win Shares

Cerv was a standout baseball and basketball player at the University of Nebraska before joining the Yankees as a reserve outfielder. He played very sparingly until the A's purchased him from the Yankees at age 30. In his second season in Kansas City, he hit .305 with 38 home runs and 104 RBI, easily the greatest season in Kansas City Athletics history. He hit .285 with twenty home runs the next season including a three home run game in August. The Yankees realized they had made a huge mistake and asked to have Cerv back. The A's were all too willing to comply, dealing Cerv for light-hitting third baseman Andy Carey.

5. Bert Campaneris 1964-1967
500 games .261/.308/.365
62 Win Shares

Campaneris was a Cuban-born shortstop, perhaps best known for his stunt in September of 1965 where he played an inning at each position on the field. He was an immensely popular player, known for his aggressiveness and his fiery temper. In his very first Major League game in 1964, he cracked two home runs, the second player ever to do so (Mark Quinn became the third!). He was a prolific base-stealer, swiping 168 bases in four seasons in Kansas City, leading the league in three of those seasons. He finished in the top ten in triples in his three full seasons in Kansas City.

Despite being really lousy, those Athletics teams never stole many bases. Usually when a team stinks offensively now, the team will try to steal a lot of bases to "manufacture runs" and it is assumed that teams have done this forever. But the Athletics did not. Aside from Campaneris, only Dick Howser ever stole more than twenty bases in a season. In 1955, the A's stole twenty-two bases - as a team. They replicated the feat in 1958. In 1960, they stole sixteen bases. I can't help but wonder if baseball commentators in the 1950s bemoaned the lack of stolen bases and complained about how players did not play the game "the right way" like players did back in the 1930s.

4. Wayne Causey 1961-1966
689 games .270/.350/.371
74 Win Shares

Causey played all over the infield in five seasons in Kansas City after being acquired in a seven player deal from the Orioles. Causey didn't hit for a lot of power, as most infielders did not in those days, but he drew quite a few walks - second most in Kansas City Athletics history. He enjoyed two solid seasons in 1964 and 1965, hitting at least .280 each season, earning MVP votes. In 1964, he finished fourth in the league in walks, sixth in hits, fifth in doubles, and was on base more times than any other player in the league. After he slumped to .261 in 1965, Causey was dealt to the White Sox. By age 31, he was out of baseball, a brief career for a promising young infielder, much like a Kansas City player twenty years later - Kurt Stillwell.

3. Jerry Lumpe 1959-1963
715 games .279/.334./377
78 Win Shares

Lumpe was an infielder for the Yankees before the A's acquired him in 1959 in the Ralph Terry/Hector Lopez deal. He is the All-Time leader in hits and runs scored for Kansas City A's. A native Missourian, he was named the starter at second base for the A's and hit .272 in his first full season in Kansas City. He was a high contact hitter, usually drawing more walks than strikeouts. He enjoyed his finest season in 1962, hitting .301 with a career high 83 RBI, and reaching double digits in home runs for the only time in his career with ten. He was eighth in batting average and second in triples, and garnered MVP votes. He slumped to .271 in 1963, but drew a career high 58 walks. That winter he was involved in a five player deal to land Tigers slugger Rocky Colavito.

Did that trade make Kansas Citians think the A's were on the verge of competing? Colavito was coming off a down year, but he was still a serious home run threat, one year removed from an MVP-type season. And Kansas City landed him for Lumpe and two mediocre pitchers. The A's were coming off a 73 win season, their best in Kansas City. Fans then must have been as excited as we were when we landed Juan Gonzalez. Colavito actually fared well in 1964, but aside from Jim Gentile, there was little support, and the pitching was awful. After just one season, he was dealt to Cleveland.

2. Ed Charles 1962-1967
726 games .268/.337/.406
83 Win Shares

Charles was a third baseman signed by the Boston Braves, but he had All-Star Joe Adcock in front of him, so he languished in the minors for years. To deal with the racism he faced as a minor leaguer in the Deep South, he wrote poetry, earning him the nickname "The Poet." You can listen to his reading on his inspiration, Jackie Robinson, here.

He ripped at the sod along the base path
As he ran in advance of a base.
On his feet were your hopes and mine
For a victory for the black man's case.

And the world is grateful for the legacy
Which he left for all humanity.
Thanks, Jackie, wherever you are.
You will always be our first superstar.


Finally, in 1962 the Braves dealt the twenty-nine year old Charles to Kansas City where he made his Major League debut. He had a sensational rookie season, hitting .288 with seventeen home runs and 74 RBI and twenty stolen bases. He posted similar numbers in 1963, hitting .267 with fifteen home runs and fifteen steals. He slumped to .241 the next year, but managed sixteen home runs and drew a career high 64 walks. Owner Charlie Finley would move the fences on Municipal Stadium back in 1965. Charles' power numbers would slip and he would fail to hit double digits in home runs the next two seasons. He did manage a career high .286 batting average in 1966. The next season he was dealt to the awful Mets. Two years later those awful Mets would stun the baseball world as World Champs with Charles at third base.

1. Norm Siebern 1960-1963
611 games .289/.381/.463
89 Win Shares

Norm was hands down the best Kansas City Athletics player in history. He is the All-Time leader in home runs and RBI. He was a St. Louis kid who signed with the Yankees. He enjoyed two fine seasons in the Bronx before he was dealt to Kansas City along with broken down vets Don Larsen and Hank Bauer, as well as first baseman Marv Throneberry for a shortstop Joe DeMaestri, first baseman Kent Hadley, and a young outfielder named Roger Maris.

The Maris deal may seem awful now, but when Maris was dealt, he seemed like a pretty ordinary power hitter. He was an All-Star in '59 with the A's, but with just sixteen home runs, it seemed unlikely he would ever chase Babe's record.

Meanwhile, the A's got four excellent seasons out of Siebern. He led the ballclub in home runs, RBI and slugging all four years in Kansas City. He was a three-time All-Star, garnering MVP votes all three seasons. He finished in the top ten in hitting twice in Kansas City, and twice finished in the top ten in RBI. His finest season was 1962. He played every single game, hit .308, drew 110 walks, hit 25 home runs, 117 RBI and finished seventh in MVP balloting. He led the A's to 72 wins, the most they had ever won in Kansas City.

His performance fell in 1963, even though the A's improved to 73 wins. He still managed to hit .273 with 16 home runs and 83 RBI, while drawing 79 walks. At the end of the year, the A's dealt him to Baltimore for slugger Jim Gentile and cash. The A's were always strapped for cash.

So there are the greats of Kansas City Athletics history. Maybe we try to forget them and their laughably bad years like a family tries to forget the black sheep of the family who besmirches their good name. Instead, I think we should embrace them. Embrace them for their awfulness. Embrace them because they represent our first shot at the big leagues. Embrace them because they are a reflection of us - our city, our community, ourselves.

Here's to you, Kansas City Athletics.

2 recs | Comment 10 comments

Read Related

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

A very nice footnote

to the “top 100 Royals” series….maybe future entries could profile the top Negro League KC Monarchs, American Association KC Blues, or the really, really old KC major league teams in the 19th century and in the Federal League.

It’s all part of the overall story of Kansas City baseball history, although the Royals will always be the biggest chapter in it.

Thanks!

Chaim Mattis Keller New York City's # 1 Royals fan!

by cmkeller on Jul 29, 2008 11:26 AM EDT   0 recs

Nice interlude!

Sarcasmâ„¢. It's the new gravy.

by jonfmorse on Jul 29, 2008 1:27 PM EDT   0 recs

Dick Howser had some solid seasons in the early 1960s

I think an injury in 1961 derailed his ROY bid.

by jbrocato on Jul 29, 2008 4:55 PM EDT   0 recs

Wow

Finley sure neglected his team (until he got to Oakland).

Shocking at the utter lack of pitching on this list.

I think the Royals new Hall of Fame building will have tributes to all former KC baseball. Hopefully, this will include the Monarchs, Blues, and Athletics.

by loyal2sdad on Jul 29, 2008 6:12 PM EDT   0 recs

Arnold Johnson

Was the owner for part of the time in Kansas City (1955-1960). He was a Chicago businessman, short on cash, who was really good friends with the Yankees GM.

He sold to Finley, but Finley ran the team on the cheap as well. And he threatened to move the team – to Seattle, to Dallas, to Peculiar, Missouri.

Relive Royals History at royalsretro.blogspot.com

by RoyalsRetro on Jul 29, 2008 8:15 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Johnson didn't sell the team, he died.

Finley bought the team from his estate.

Absolutely excellent post, though. I thoroughly enjoyed it.

You can't sit on a lead and run a few plays into the line and just kill the clock. You've got to throw the ball over the goddamn plate and give the other man his chance. That's why baseball is the greatest game of them all. ~Earl Weaver

by UncleLeo on Aug 6, 2008 8:33 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Thanks for the trip

down memory lane. Grew up in Cedar Rapids, IA, a KC A’s fan. Each year my dad took my brother and me to a game (he was diehard NYY). My heart went with the A’s to Oakland and, as frustrating as it is sometimes, my day still rises or falls with the result of their games. I remember every one of these guys from the KC days and, I think, watched each of them play at one time or another.

by samljm on Jul 29, 2008 9:27 PM EDT   0 recs

Born in Cedar Rapids

Only lived there a couple years though

Royals, NBA, Golden Hurricane, Hawkeyes, Chiefs, and KU basketball, in that order.

by Rowyal on Jul 30, 2008 12:22 AM EDT   0 recs

What might have been?

Hello from AthleticsNation. Congrats on the sweep (grumble).

Nate Bass would have made that list if he didn’t hurt his arm after his rookie year.

And really, the greatest player ever to play for the Kansas City Athletics, or the Athletics in general (albeit only 3 innings), was Satchel Paige.

"All managers are losers, they are the most expendable pieces of furniture on the face of the Earth."- Ted Williams

by Gaijin_Suketto on Aug 7, 2008 1:46 PM EDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about Kansas City Royals.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Fredo-corleone_pictureboxart_160w_small
Projecting the Royals' 2009 Pitching With Bill James (Seriously, It's Just a Title)
Royalsretro_small
The Best Free Agent Signings in Royals History
Small
Value Over Replacement Defender
Nyroyal3a_small
Royals 2009 Payroll (including projections)

Recent FanPosts

Nyroyal3a_small
Royals Confidence Index - December
Small
One move that will improve the Royals
Small
Projected wins?
Clemente_small
OK SO MAYBE JACOBS AT 3B WAS A JOKE, BUT KC WINNING THE CENTRAL IS NOT
Clemente_small
KC ROYALS JUST 15 WINS AWAY! THAT'S IT
Zackgreinke2_small
Final RR top prospect list
Aquinas_small
Mental Help: More Discussion on Biancalana
Small
Depth Chart
Steve_balboni_pose_small
Royals Auditioning For Greinke

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Site Meter