"Simply put, I think the Cy Young should go to the best pitcher and the MVP to the best player, regardless of a team's record. With so many other factors that can affect a team's win total, all players need to be given equal consideration for these awards."

Ok, so he also mentions K-Rod as a contender for the Cy Young (although he does say Cliff Lee should win it), and that broke my heart a little, but still, has an active player ever been a member of the BBWAA?