Royals Review: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Uga VII, Requiescat in Pace: A Tribute to a Damn Good 'Dawg

Royals Minor League Roundtable: An Improving, But Far From Finished Player Development System

Now, more than ever, the ability of the Royals player development system to produce both stars and useful Major Leaguers, stands out as the question dictating the viability of the Moore regime. Last week, I contacted two Royals bloggers who follow the minors closely, as well our own RR contributor and "minor league guy" Darren/nwroyal.

Keith is the man behind The Royal Tower, while Kenneth writes The Pipeline, two well-run and regularly updated sites that make the lives of all of us easier. Meanwhile, Darren can be credited with not only raising the bar on prospect coverage here at RR, he's spared you all from Will overload. You can read Darren's work on Royals Review here.

Unfortunately, I bothered these guys BEFORE the Betancourt trade, although in some ways that may be a good thing. Dan Cortes comes up a few times, so you can consider this a time capsule of what we thought before the trade that shook the faith of millions took place.

 

RR: Do you have a particular team or element of the system (pitchers, position players, high school guys, etc.) that you really like to follow?

Keith@ The Royal Tower: I enjoy following the whole system, but I think I like to follow the pitchers just a bit more. I love nothing more than to watch a pitcher's duel. I'd like to think I know a little bit more about pitching than hitting, so naturally it's more interesting for me to predict, project, and follow.

Kenneth@ The Pipeline: Every level has its attractions for me. At AAA, you hopefully have the guys who are close to making it, even though with the Royals the last few years it's mostly been retreads with a couple C-level prospects at Omaha. AA seems to be where the Royals like to put their prospects to the test -- if you remember, a few years back, Baird seemed to like to ignore AAA and move guys straight from Wichita to KC. It's not quite like that nowadays under Dayton Moore, but NW Arkansas is now usually the team to watch each year in the minors part of the organization. The Carolina League is a competitive league, so you get the feeling the prospects that make it at Wilmington are worth their salt. Unfortunately, that hasn't always been the case for KC -- take Rowdy Hardy, for example, who dominated the Carolina League a couple years back but couldn't hack it at AA. Dan Cortes also hasn't exactly excelled in AA. Burlington is also a good test, more for hitters than pitchers as it's a good pitchers' league. I had hoped Moustakas would do better there this year -- his lacking OBP has been a disappointment. The rookie leagues are a crapshoot -- you've got Idaho Falls in the hitter-friendly Pioneer League, which I think veils a little bit what a guy is bringing with the bat, kinda like when the High-A team was in High Desert. You've got Burlington in the Appalachian League, which may be the most competitive rookie league, and then you've got the AZL Royals in another very hitter-friendly environment.

I guess that's a long way of saying, no, there's no particular team I like to follow. I'd say at the moment, I'm wanting desperately to see some good position prospects emerge. You've got Hosmer doing OK, not great at Burlington, and you've got Moustakas scuffling along in Wilmington, and then it's level. Chris Lubanski had me going early in the year until his mysterious hamstring injury that he's missed a great deal of time for. I'd rather see the Royals take a couple good college position players early in the draft, just one time, and work the pitchers around that rather than the other way around. I can understand, I guess, going after Aaron Crow, but with Grant Green, a bonafide top college SS on the board? Wow. I guess I see the organization's needs differently than the front office.

Darren @ Royals Review: I've gravitated towards following the draft. The interest level and amount of information about it has exploded in the past couple of years. The Royals drafts use to be a one player affair--our top pick and then a bunch of junk after that but the Royals have had some deep drafts the past few years. Teams are figuring out that the current slotting system is an uneven playing field and it will reward those who are willing to buck the system. The Royals are one of those teams and I think its a really smart move. And what other area of the Royals organization can you say "they are doing something really smart"?

RR: Who would you label as the top prospect in the system?

Darren@ Royals Review: I go with Eric Hosmer. He hasn't taken off yet but he gets on base and supposedly has huge power potential. John Sickels reported just the other day that he talked to a scout who was still high on Hosmer but thought he had developed some mechanical issues that were hurting him. I think (or perhaps hope) that he will break out in the 2nd half like Moustakas last year. I think when he get up and running he will be a classic slugger like we haven't seen on a Royals team in a long time: big power, lots of walks and doesn't hurt you in the field.

Star-divide

Kenneth@ The Pipeline: Right now I'd have to say Wilmington lefty Danny Duffy, his recent struggles aside. The easy answer is Moustakas or Hosmer, but I really think Duffy can be something special. Moustakas had a great second half at Burlington last year but it looks at this point, with a .300 OBP and 18 BB/51 K in 77 G/297 ABs at Wilmington, that he's not exactly tearing up Advanced-A ball, but, then again, it is the Carolina League, so all is not lost. Hosmer has a similar BA, better OBP and worse SLG at a level one lower and has shown much more patience at the plate. It's easier to see the power coming along with time with Hosmer, and it has to be taken into account how the Midwest League favors pitchers. The only other top prospect candidate at this point is Dan Cortes, and his struggles with command have seemed to come back -- 35 BB/32 K over his last 10 starts. In my mind, I can see Duffy being a top-two starter, maybe a third starter eventually in KC. I don't see Cortes being any more than a back-of-the-rotation guy at this point, if that. On another note, I like what we've seen out of Mike Montgomery this year in Burlington. Another win tonight (July 9) and 1 or less earned runs in 9 of his last 10 starts. He's gonna be rocketing up a lot of Royals prospect charts.

Keith@ The Royal Tower:  For me, it's Aaron Crow. Partially due to the lame season's of Hosmer and Moustakas, but it's more a credit to Crow's talents. He throws three above average pitches with command. The layoff is going to affect him initially, but he's going to get to KC quickly once he's back in the groove.

RR: Do you have a favorite "sleeper" prospect?

Keith@ The Royal Tower: I think saying Disco Hayes would be kind of lame at this point...who doesn't love him? I'll throw out two -- Keaton Hayenga and John Lamb. Hayenga's got fantastic stuff and it'll be interesting to see how his command comes along as he continues to get further away from labrum surgery. Lamb is more of a pitchability guy now, but he's tall and lanky and could add some ticks to the fastball. He already "knows how to pitch," and if his stuff can come along...he could really be a good one.

Darren@ Royals Review: David Lough has been someone I've liked--he's in the middle of what looks to be a breakout season. He's kind of a David DeJesus guy--not huge power and kind of a tweener in the OF--but his bat will play and he will give good production at a low cost. I'll throw out one more guy who I'm big on is Yowil Espinal. He was a big (for us, at least) international signing for us 2 years ago. He's a SS who is having a great year for the Burlington Royals. He has big time tools on offense and defense. Every part of his games has taken a big step forward and I don't think he'll be a sleeper for very long.

Kenneth@ The Pipeline: I suppose Montgomery isn't really a sleeper at this point. He was a supplemental 1st rounder, after all. How about NWA OF David Lough or Burlington (A) OF Nick Van Stratten? Lough had a great start at Wilmington and has continued to hit at NW Arkansas in his first taste of AA. Plus he seems to have a decent arm and defense. Van Stratten doesn't hit for power but has speed and defense and has stayed on the field while keeping his BA over .300 at Burlington. Lough doesn't walk much, tho, and Van Stratten has shown some good discipline. I'd like to see what Van Stratten could do in the Carolina League.

RR: Who has been the most disappointing prospect this season?

Kenneth@The Pipeline: Probably Cortes, who has been touted as the top pitching prospect just in time for all his command problems to resurface. The recent arrest is just the cherry on top, even if it was somewhat innocuous. Mario Lisson would be a close second, but I don't know how seriously anyone took him as a prospect. He got a 40-man slot to keep him out of the rule 5 draft, then stunk in AA last year, stunk AGAIN in AA this year, then got a promotion to Omaha for some reason, where he has somehow stunk slightly less than he did in AA. Then you've got the Wilmington trio of Moustakas, Derrick Robinson and Adrian Ortiz, Moustakas being the biggest disappointment there. A .300 OBP, and leading the team in errors, meaning he's probably gonna need to be moved off 3B too? If that's not disappointing... Robinson's BA has declined, his steal rate is down, so he's now a 2-tool player -- speed and D. I had high hopes for Ortiz this year, too, and he hasn't hacked it in Wilmington, and doesn't have the excuse of a lack of playing time.

Keith@ The Royal Tower: There have been more than a few disappointments, but I'll say Derrick Robinson. I've been touting him for a while, but his bat just isn't progressing as it should. If anything he has gone backwards.

Darren@ Royals Review: Dan Gutierrez--simply because he hasn't thrown a pitch this year and I predicted before the season began he would be our top prospect when 2009 ended. He has battled injury, personal issues and had a spat with the Royals regarding his recovery from injury. Also, Moustakas and Hosmer apparently talked him into joining Scott Boras Corp.--but that also has a positive side because Boras wouldn't take him unless they thought he had potential.

RR: Typically, the Royals' system is presented as improving, but still immature. In particular, is there anyone in Omaha (other than Kila) who we should be excited about, or who at least could help the team soon?

Darren@ Royals Review: "Disco" Hayes is down there and he could help the team but I'm not sure how much the Royals believe in him. Mario Lisson is better than TPJ...(crickets chirping). Omaha is kind of a wasteland but we have got some talent starting to show up in Northwest Arkansas.

Kenneth@ The Pipeline: My answer would be, not that I see, or at least nobody that's a "prospect". If the Royals hang on to lefty Lenny DiNardo, he could help some maybe at the MLB level, but then again, why wouldn't he be there already if they thought he could help? Chris Hayes is a cult hero among Royals fans, but I'm unconvinced. He's gotten guys out at every level, but at some point his speed is gonna meet its match with the bats. I'd love to see him become the next Quiz, tho. With his blog, he could be the Quiz's match in several ways.

I like to think the Quiz could have written a good blog. I thought going into the year that Carlos Rosa could maybe chip in in KC, but he has really struggled out of the pen for Omaha. I'd rather they had kept him in the rotation, but he wasn't staying healthy there, so that's a tough situation. Position-wise, it's pretty bereft in Omaha. Tug Hulett has done nothing in his sparse chances, Irving Falu has had a solid year in AAA but doesn't dazzle, Lubanski and Shane Costa have been hurt, Ryan Shealy too, I also had hopes (I've been saying that a lot) that Travis Metcalf would be a good pickup from the Rangers, but that hasn't panned out, either. Scott Thorman, a Dayton-ex-Brave pickup, has been great for Omaha but I have a feeling he'd probably struggle in KC.

Keith@ The Royal Tower: A few relievers come to mind, namely Disco and Carlos Rosa. I know Rosa's had a down season, but the stuff is still plenty there. He's hit 96 and 97 multiple times on the stadium gun at the games i've been to. Infielder Irving Falu would be a better option than the two no-hit SS's were currently employing. He can play all over the infield and has even played some right field. He might be a switch hitting Bloomquist type, which has a bit of value. Injuries really hurt Chris Lubanski's shot to potentially help the big league team earlier this year as he was having a nice little opening to the year. Overall there are some guys that could play roles on the Major league roster, but no one other than Ka'aihue that will likely make a major impact.

RR: How would you describe the state of the system as a whole right now? How confident are you in Dayton Moore's ability to build a strong enough minor league/player development system for the Royals to win the AL Central and beyond?

Keith@ The Royal Tower: System is doing well, but it could be a whole heck of a lot better. Unfortunately our three top prospects coming into the year have stumbled a bit in Moustakas, Hosmer, and Cortes. On the other side of the coin, other young players have emerged as very real prospects such as Bianchi, Lough, Parraz, and Espinal. I'm going to cop out a little here, but I think we still need a couple more years to see how Dayton & Co. (the "Co." are the people who make the picks) will really do with the minor leagues. What I do know is him and his staff are not afraid to take who they truly believe is the top talents in the draft, not just in the first round, but in subsequent rounds as well (highlighted by this year's draft). Not only that, but they have heavily increased efforts to find talent in the international field (also highlighted this year with Korean C Shin Jin-Ho and Nicaraguan 3B Cheslor Cuthbert). More talent is coming into the system now than at any point in the past two decades, and while there will be busts/disappointments, this is the way to build long time because some players will work out, and not just work out, but become star players.

Kenneth@ The Pipeline: The state of the system is better than the Baird years, which isn't saying much, but I wouldn't exactly put the Royals in the upper echelon of major league systems. I'd give it a solid C, when the Royals need it to be at least a B to compete. I think Moore has concentrated too much in recent times of building up the pitching side of the ledger and leaving the position side as an afterthought. As others (namely Rany Jazayerli, but others) have pointed out, he seems to have a good idea of potential future value but horrible idea of present value of certain players. Signings like Guillen and Farnsworth trouble me, as does the Jacobs trade when the Royals had Kila Ka'aihue waiting for a chance to play, at a much cheaper cost. Obviously the Royals aren't gonna be able to buy their way to the top, so they have to build it. I wrote recently I think Moore is a good assistant GM, but he hasn't convinced me that he's a good GM yet. The whole ex-Braves thing aggravates me, too. Are we really gonna build our way to the top using players the Braves get rid of? He basically uses his 25-30 draft signings each year, plus picks up whoever the Braves don't want anymore in the offseason and during the season. My confidence in Moore is low, but I'm waiting to be convinced.

Darren@ Royals Review: The state of the Royals system continues to improve. The Royals have several good prospects on each team from Northwest Arkansas, Wilmington, Burlington-IA, Idaho Falls, Burlington-NC. The Royals last two drafts look very good so far and we are seeing fruit from their increased budget on the International front. The Royals have a lot of pitching depth and their hitting depth is improving.

I think Dayton Moore can build a minor league system that is as strong as any in the AL Central--but it won't matter if we keep signing the Guillens and Farnsworths of the world. A very good farm system--by itself--probably won't translate into a division title. I don't see Moustakas and Hosmer being ready in time to help while Greinke is still here (I hope I'm wrong). David Glass won't want to keep spending record amount on the draft if we don't start seeing wins as the big league level. Also, the Royals need to have the guts to flip some guys for prospects this year. So I would say I'm torn--I really like the direction of the minors but loathe the direction of the big league club--I have a hard time reconciling those two things. I guess I keep hoping that Moore will have an epiphany about the big league club.

I hope I didn't jumble up anyone's answers! Thanks again to Keith, Kenneth, and Darren. Be sure to visit The Royal Tower and The Pipeline the next time you surf.

5 recs  |  Comment 30 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Excellent, excellent post...

Thanks for the info. This has been a pretty depressing year all around. It’s hard when the only thing going for your best two hitting prospects is that they’re posting not quite abysmal numbers playing in pitchers’ leagues.

by billexgordler on Jul 14, 2009 9:40 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Good post

It’s good to hear some opinions. I may not agree with them all. But it’s still good to hear them.

I too am disappointed in Lisson (haven’t even heard his name this year), Rosa (same thing), and the AAA club. I still think Rosa gets the Sept. callup and does decent. He needs to get it figured out soon so that he can help us at the MLB level.

I thought it was interesting to hear that some other people feel that Cortes was a disappointment. Here’s a theory. Cortes wins a pitcher of the year award, comes into the camp thinking he doesn’t stink when he poops, and doesn’t work as hard as he did the year before thinking he’s got this figured out. Then he doesn’t do great and has to work hard to catch up. Maybe he doesn’t do it full-heartedly? The Royals see this and move him out.

Coffee. The NEW Performance Enhancing drug for Sport's Writers. Just ask Ken Rosenthal.

by 306008 on Jul 14, 2009 10:12 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

I’m wondering if they were simply disheartened with Cortes, then the arrest gave them the reason they needed to deal him. I wonder how seriously they were shopping him before he pissed in public.

by royalspipeline on Jul 14, 2009 2:33 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

but i guess in one respect he was a perfect guy to trade

still valued, but slipping

o/c the guy to be traded for was not supposed to be YUNEFI

by royalsreview on Jul 14, 2009 4:00 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

The classic sell high

Coffee. The NEW Performance Enhancing drug for Sport's Writers. Just ask Ken Rosenthal.

by 306008 on Jul 15, 2009 10:56 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Great job, all

I have a question and a comment and I’ll listen off the air.

Question: Even when we start getting more prospects to Omaha, will the front office recognize them? The last two years we’ve had obvious upgrades sitting there (Aviles and Kila) while the Royals twittled their thumbs hoping TPJ and Jacobs could magically morph into beautiful baseball butterflies. ( I don’t give credit for the eventual promo of Aviles because it came much later than it should and the front office did nothing but berate him even as he posted the best SS season we’re likely to see here for a while.)

The comment: Beware of strong second-half showings by Moose and Hoz, because this is the time of year when many of the best A-ball prospects are promoted, diluting the leagues’ talent pools, especially in the Midwest league

Baseball's that swingy stick game, right?

by royalsroyalsroyals on Jul 14, 2009 10:53 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Great point

About second half performance

Relive Royals History at royalsretro.blogspot.com

by RoyalsRetro on Jul 14, 2009 11:16 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

second half performances are the currency of baesball

© 2008 Royals

I'm not a sabermetrician, but I do play one at Driveline Mechanics.

Can't get enough of me? Check out my Twitter feed.

by devil_fingers on Jul 14, 2009 11:56 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Our own prospects

The test case will be Kila, won’t it? I don’t think he’s going to be an All-Star—but he will give good production for the league minimum. Nothing would surprise me at this point. Poz had a very good blog post talking about how the Royals mgmt is not full of stupid people—they just have some big blind spots and perhaps they are willfully ignorant to those spots. Someone like Kila could very well fit into those spots.

The point about 2nd half performance seems like a factor—but not a huge factor-especially at the low minors. At AA and AAA it might be more true—but look at the Burlington Bees—their pitching is better now than it was at the beginning of the year b/c they held back Montgomery/Melville in Ext ST. Several teams follow the same pattern.

by nwroyal on Jul 14, 2009 2:24 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Outstanding stuff

I like their realist approach – too many Royals fans I think are a bit too optimistic about some of our players. I agree in their criticisms of Dayton’s approach – too much emphasis on high upside pitching IMO. It will either be a brilliant strategy or it will blow up in his face – I don’t see much middle ground.

Relive Royals History at royalsretro.blogspot.com

by RoyalsRetro on Jul 14, 2009 11:16 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Not a line you read on RR very often.
too many Royals fans I think are a bit too optimistic about some of our players.

If you were thinking, you wouldn't have thought that.

http://sonsofsamhorn.net/index.php?showforum=129

by Warden11 on Jul 14, 2009 11:30 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

I think this is evident

with some people’s opinions regarding the Duffy and Montgomery types and with Kila. Duffy and Montgomery are two good pitching prospects in A ball. They have a much better chance of failure than of success (being a good 2-3 starter), given that they are not elite level prospects and that they’re still in A ball. Kila might end up being something, but he’s far from a lock. He hasnt really earned himself a call up. Would he be worse than Jacobs? Probably not, but that doesnt mean he’s ready for the bigs. Make him earn it, as the Royals have stated they will do. If he starts hitting again through the end of August, give him a legit shot in September and in ST next year.

Fire Everyone

by billybeingbilly on Jul 14, 2009 11:40 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Wasn't this the plan last year?
give him a legit shot in September and in ST next year.

The only reason I can see not getting him up by the end of July is the hope of trading him. They might be afraid of him coming up and flopping and then losing all trade value.

If you were thinking, you wouldn't have thought that.

http://sonsofsamhorn.net/index.php?showforum=129

by Warden11 on Jul 14, 2009 11:48 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

CLUBHOUSE CONFUSION!

Relive Royals History at royalsretro.blogspot.com

by RoyalsRetro on Jul 14, 2009 11:51 AM EDT up reply actions   1 recs

well...he hasnt exactly hit his way onto this roster.

Is he a better option than Jacobs right now? Likely. Has he earned a full time major league shot? No, not in my opinion.

Fire Everyone

by billybeingbilly on Jul 14, 2009 11:54 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Kila

I had hopes he’d continue his ‘08 tear this season, too, and he hasn’t been light years away from that, just a lower BA, more sneaky power production. Still getting on-base tho.

by royalspipeline on Jul 14, 2009 2:35 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

My thoughts

I am not discouraged by Hosmer at all – he is drawing walks, K’s are at an acceptable level, and I think the power will come soon enough.

Moustakas is a bit discouraging, primarily because of his plate discipline. I think he will hit for enough power, even if moved to the OF, but will he end up being just another low OBP power hitter, or a good overall hitter?

Surprised nobody was talking up Bianchi – he has run the gamut from excellent to poor, but some of that can surely be explained by injuries, and he seems to have turned the corner this season, right?

I think I am more optimistic about Montgomery than this post. Love his command, and gotta love his very impressive G/F ratio. Granted, low A ball is a LONG way from the majors – but he sure seems to have the makeup you are looking for in a pitcher.

I’m not as down on Rosa as this post either. Yes, his numbers are down this year – but he has done much better over the last month after a rough start. We all know how fickle ERA can be for a reliever, what with small sample sizes always being an issue. Glad to read that his stuff is still there, apparently.

Would love to see the organization do something different this September; i.e., PLAY the callups. Let Kila start for 20 games, let Rosa and perhaps Hayes get some meaningful appearances in the bullpen.

Mr Glass, this is a pro sports team, not a retail store - run it like one!

by loyal2sdad on Jul 14, 2009 12:23 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

also a big fan of montgomery

between montgomery, duffy, and crow, we’ve got some real potential in the low minors

by marbotty on Jul 14, 2009 1:01 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

oh and as for hosmer

i’m only discouraged in that he’s not Justin Smoak. but hey, whatever

by marbotty on Jul 14, 2009 1:04 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

i am very high on montgomery also

he’s a clear #4 in the system for me right now behind crow, moose, hosmer. big, tall workhorse type pitcher with chance for three above average ML pitches.

baseball rules.

by doublestix on Jul 15, 2009 3:51 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Great roundtable -- thanks to everyone involved

Rec’d and retweeted… I hope all the negativity didn’t drive Keith away from here, seems like he hasn’t posted for a long time.

I'm not a sabermetrician, but I do play one at Driveline Mechanics.

Can't get enough of me? Check out my Twitter feed.

by devil_fingers on Jul 14, 2009 12:29 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

i didn't die

although they’re trying

baseball rules.

by doublestix on Jul 15, 2009 3:52 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Nice Job

the funniest thing about this particular signature is that by the time you realise it doesn't say anything it's too late to stop reading it!

by ratherfantastic on Jul 14, 2009 3:08 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about Kansas City Royals.
Start posting about the Royals »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Trust_small
Denny Matthews at Plaza Library
Royalsretro_small
Royals sign P Jorge Campillo
Stash1_small
Kansas City Fails To Pick Up Option On Royals
Royalsretro_small
Royals sign P Brad Thompson
Tu_small
What would be an appropriate haul for Greinke?
Small
Shane Costa and Ryan Shealy Eras Officially End
Royalsreview_small
Predictions: Will Greinke Win the Cy Young?
Small
Saturday in the AFL
Royalsreview_small
Royals Links: DeJesus Rumors, Chunky Moose, Gold Glove Outrage, Pete Rose's Galpal, Bill Simmons, Lech Walesa and Rany's Return
Rollinsliar_small
Similarity Scores through 2009

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

Royalsreview_small royalsreview