The 2009 MLB Big Market vs. Small Market All-Star Game

I made an off-hand comment in the ASG game thread about how I'd like to see the ASG be a game between the big-market and small-market teams, and billybeingbilly challenged me to come up with the rosters.

So, I did.

First, I took everything into account as it was; everyone who got elected got elected, and if the starters for both leagues both happened to be from the same market section, then I got creative; mostly due to laziness and a wonky internet, I used CBS Sportsline's player ratings in cases where I needed to pluck a player out of the pool of players who didn't actually get selected to the All-Star game.  Same thing with the player balloting (players got in based on their final player vote totals until I ran out of spaces), and the final five vote.

The breakdown of the markets was based on some older info, but still close enough for government work.  The big-market teams are NYY, NYM, LAA, LAD, BOS, PHI, DET, HOU, CHC, CHW, TEX, BAL, WAS, ATL, and TOR; the small-markets are FLA, SEA, OAK, SFG, CLE, STL, ARI, SDP, MIN, TBY, COL, PIT, CIN, KCR, and MIL.

* - injured
ITALICS: wasn't on either real ASG roster

Big-Market All-Star Roster:

MGR: Charlie Manuel, PHI
Coaches: Joe Torre, LAD; Cito Gaston, TOR (I'd guess)

C: Brian McCann, ATL
1B: Mark Teixiera, NYY
2B: Dustin Pedroia, BOS*
3B: David Wright, NYM
SS: Derek Jeter, NYY
LF: Jason Bay, BOS
CF: Carlos Beltran, NYM*
RF: Raul Ibanez, PHI

Player Balloting:
C: Jason Varitek, BOS (yes, really; best big-market catcher not already on the roster)
1B: Kevin Youkilis, BOS
2B: Chase Utley, PHI (NL starter, so he gets the nod here, and would start in place of the injured Pedroia)
3B: Ryan Zimmerman, WAS
SS: Miguel Tejada, HOU
OF: Josh Hamilton, TEX (AL starter, bumped by Beltran, and would start in place of Beltran)
OF: Torii Hunter, LAA*
OF: Curtis Granderson, DET
SP: Roy Halladay, TOR
SP: Johan Santana, NYM
SP: Justin Verlander, DET
SP: Chad Billingsley, LAD
SP: Edwin Jackson, DET
RP: Francisco Rodriguez, NYM
RP: Jonathan Papelbon, BOS
RP: Jonathan Broxton, LAD*

Manager/MLB Selections:
P: Ted Lilly, CHC (gotta have a Cub)
P: Mark Buehrle, CHW (gotta have a Chisux)
P: Josh Beckett, BOS
P: Mariano Rivera, NYY
1B: Ryan Howard, PHI (as much flack as Manuel got, he actually was the next-best 1B among big-market teams)
2B: Aaron Hill, TOR
OF: Hunter Pence, HOU
OF: Adam Jones, BAL (gotta have an Oriole)

Final Vote:
OF: Shane Victorino, PHI

Injury Replacements:
3B: Brandon Inge, DET (AL winner, so we'll have him replace Pedroia rather than Figgins, who replaced Longoria)
OF: Nelson Cruz, TEX (replaces Torii Hunter)
OF: Jayson Werth, PHI (replaces Beltran)
RP: Brian Fuentes, LAA (replaces Broxton)

Small-Market All-Star Roster:

Manager: Joe Maddon, TBY
Coaches: Don Wakamatsu, SEA; Tony LaRussa, STL (obviously would get the nod over Trey, and we're all happier that way anyway)

C: Joe Mauer, MIN
1B: Albert Pujols, STL
2B: Freddy Sanchez, PIT (next-best small-market 2B, plus we need a Pirate, although we'll get another one after the fact)
3B: Evan Longoria, TBY*
SS: Hanley Ramirez, FLA
LF: Ryan Braun, MIL
CF: Ichiro Suzuki, SEA
RF: Brad Hawpe, COL (top small-market votegetter among OF)

Player Ballot:
C: Yadier Molina, STL (no, really; he got five more votes than Victor Martinez, mostly because the NL has no catchers.  We can put Martinez here and I'm fine with it, just following my own rules.)
1B: Adrian Gonzalez, SDP (beat Morneau by two votes, and I'm perfectly okay with that.)
2B: Ben Zobrist, TBY (god only knows who led small-market 2B in the balloting since the top two in both leagues were from big-market teams.  Zobrist is the 2nd highest-rated small-market 2B in CBS's ratings.)
3B: Pablo Sandoval, SFG (really! and he gets to START with Longoria hurt!)
SS: Jason Bartlett, TBY
OF: Carl Crawford, TBY
OF: Justin Upton, ARI
OF: Shin-Soo Choo, CLE (highest-rated OF not on the roster, plus we need an Indian if we don't have V-Mart anyway.)
SP: Zack Greinke, KCR (he's still the only Royal.)
SP: Tim Lincecum, SFG
SP: Matt Cain, SFG*
SP: Josh Johnson, FLA
SP: Felix Hernandez, SEA
RP: Joe Nathan, MIN
RP: Heath Bell, SDP
RP: Francisco Cordero, CIN

Manager/MLB Selections:
P: Andrew Bailey, OAK
P: Dan Haren, ARI (hey, better him than Wakefield)
P: Jason Marquis, COL
P: Ryan Franklin, STL
1B: Justin Morneau, MIN
2B: Brandon Phillips, CIN (there really weren't many other IF options here)
OF: Justin Upton, ARI
OF: Matt Holliday, OAK (next-best OF by CBS ratings)

Final Vote:
1B: Carlos Pena, TBY (I can only guess here, of course.)

Injury Replacements:
3B: Mark Reynolds (replaces Longoria)
P: Zach Duke, PIT (replaces Cain)

Who got knocked off the rosters?

Victor Martinez (or Molina, take your pick)
Michael Young (too bad, so sad)
Prince Fielder (victim of numbers)

Arguments and accusations of snubbery may now commence!

This FanPost was written by a member of the Royals Review community. It does not necessarily reflect the views of the editors and writers of this site.

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Royals Review

You must be a member of Royals Review to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Royals Review. You should read them.

Join Royals Review

You must be a member of Royals Review to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Royals Review. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.