FanPost

Optimism gives way to reality

Mission 2012 is finally upon us. Spring Training began with abundant optimism. Would this finally be the year the Royals would get out of their own way and compete? Sure, the Tigers signed Prince Fielder, but a more consistent rotation (sans Kyle Davies) and continued development of prospects (Hosmer, Moose, Perez, and Giavotella) had positioned the Royals nicely. Opening day seemed like something special. But as Royals fans, and more specifically as regular readers of this site, we knew there HAD to be something afoot... Boy were we right... Royals-salvador-perez-needs-knee-surgery-u2158t70-x-large_medium

via i.usatoday.net

Not long into camp, many scouts and those who track pitchers' velocity became alarmed at the lack of pop on the newly acquired Jonathan Sanchez's fastball. While typically sitting in the 92-94 range, he came in humming it in at 87-89, with his typical lack of command (the mythical three strikes in a row may have occured this spring...). Bruce Chen was getting shelled, somewhat predictably. THEN, Danny Duffy pitched the best two innings (2ip, 0h, 0bb, 0r, 5k)anyone has seen since... well, since Jeremy Affeldt, which ought to give some pause to this whole idea. Paulino also continued to struggle. Thank God for Luis Mendoza (has anyone ever written that?), the only pitcher who has given cause for optimism, or curiosity or intrigue depending on your thoughts on him. 837-1dmqtm

via media.kansascity.com

Giavotella, Perez, and Moustakas all struggled to start camp. Cain dominated (and has continued to do so). Perez went hitless; Giavotella and Moose had no extra-base pop and were struggling. Surely, Perez would start hitting like most contact hitters do, and surely Gio's numbers wouldn't tempt management into starting Getz or Betancourt over him, denying the prospect the chance to develop in favor of tried and true big league failures. Moustakas, while he struggled offensively, intrigued fans and scouts with his trimmed frame and slick defense (again, has that been written before?). Speculation regarding his hitting was relegated to the "he's a slow starter" file. 10iour

via media.kansascity.com

Then, Salvador Perez signs a contract extension! Hooray! We are set at a cornerstone position for 7 years! The pessimists should have noticed this as the turning point and predicted the coming calamity. Perez, hitless in the spring, injured his knee stretching for a wide pitch thrown by (guess, go ahead) Jonathan Sanchez in warmups. He had a torn meniscus, and the prognosis following surgery was the very cautious kind; Perez will be out until June at the earliest. A previous injury to one of the contenders for his backup spot, Manny Pina, had gone mostly unnoticed due to the overwhelming optimism surrounding the club. The Royals were left with the mediocre-hitting and awful defense of Brayan Pena and non-prospect Max Ramirez. Then, another predictable calamity befell this cursed franchise, the team's most reliable reliever (except for April and May last year), closer Joakim Soria, had an elbow injury. He had damage to his UCL, requiring Tommy John Surgery. So long Mexicutioner! Thankfully, we have Greg Holland and Jonathan Broxton, in addition to Louis Coleman, Kevin Herrera, and other relievers who appear competent to handle the closer role. But things certainly had lost their luster surrounding this team. Gyi0065091384_extra_large_medium

via cdn1.sbnation.com

So with the injury component out of the way, it was management's turn to rear its ugly head to ruin our wildest dreams pertaining to the 2012 season. Every year, the Royals make a seemingly useless move to acquire a need that really is non-existent and created by reading too much into Spring Training. This year, we needed a catcher due to Perez's injury. Management longs for an all-defense, no-hitting guy at every position, so why would this be different? Humberto Quintero it is, arguably the worst hitter in the majors (we already had Getz and Betancourt). With him came Jason Bourgeois, a speedy outfielder with some infield ability who only showed promise in a half-season audition with the Astros last year. Mitch Maier and Jarrod Dyson became expendable to a degree (though each had a shot at a roster spot, Maier due to options and Dyson because that'swhatspeeddo). However, we gave up a legitimate prospect for these two bench-players-at-best, left-handed reliever Kevin Chapman, a hard throwing pitcher who has had tremendous strikeout numbers in the minors, though those have not translated to awe-inspiring other statistics. Given the lack of anything intriguing about Houston, Chapman's timetable for reaching the majors just rapidly approached, while the Royals did not get better. 940-quintero-humberto-8col_medium

via www.cbc.ca

Then the Royals did something that should have been foreseeable but really smacks in the face of everything they talk about: they didn't trust the PROCESS. The Royals optioned Giavotella to AAA to allow Getz and Betancourt to play at second base. Giavotella destroyed AAA pitching last year, much moreso than even Moustakas ever did (admittedly, with less power), landed with a splash in the majors, only to fade off considerably the last month of the year. His sub-par numbers gave pause to many prospect-buffs, and his continued below average defense somehow led the Royals to re-sign Yunieski Betancourt this offseason. Then it was revealed Giavotella was playing injured, and he had surgery in the winter. Though he had proven all he could at the minor league level, he showed up to spring playing slightly better defense but without the hitting ability he had displayed in past years. Management went back to the only thing they knew how to do, replace him with failed veterans. Getz and Betancourt would be mainstays on the team in 2012, at least until Giavotella proved something (that he needs more grit, presumably) to management. S100722_11base-pg-horizontal_jpg_medium

via i.usatoday.net

So here we are. Our opening day lineup may look like this: Gordon LF, Cain CF, Hosmer 1B, Butler DH, Frenchy RF, Moose 3B (has also hit like crap this spring), Getz/Betancourt 2B, Quintero C, Escobar SS. Add to that the inspring meaning of the move, embodied by Chris Getz being enthusiastic about his ability to relax and work on his bunting (he actually said this), and the follow-up sacrifice bunt in the first inning of a game, we are positioned for some serious anger and disappointment for the first half of the 2012 season. Mission 2012 looks a lot like 2011 right now. "Our Time" became Quintero, Getz, and Betancourt. While optimistic just a few weeks ago, reality stepped in, and today we are where we are comfortable as Royals fans: pessimistic and ready for an uninspiring summer.

This FanPost was written by a member of the Royals Review community. It does not necessarily reflect the views of the editors and writers of this site.

SB Nation Featured Video
X
Log In Sign Up

forgot?
Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Royals Review

You must be a member of Royals Review to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Royals Review. You should read them.

Join Royals Review

You must be a member of Royals Review to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Royals Review. You should read them.

Spinner.vc97ec6e

Authenticating

Great!

Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.

tracking_pixel_9351_tracker