I won't give any analysis, I just want a poll. Unfortunately, one has to use at least 75 words to publish a FanPost. People in the comment section are free to give reasons for their answers.
People are free to mention names like Aoki and Dyson in their comments, if they so desire. Others may wish to mention memories of Raul earlier in the 21st Century. Personally, I do like Raul Ibanez and hope that he can find his hitting stroke, but having Mr. Ibanez retire wearing our uniform would be somewhat of a small honor for the franchise.
Winners get bragging rights all winter long.