Royals Insider: Joey Gathright
On this edition of Royals Insider, we explore the life and times of Joey Renard Gathright.
Born in Hattiesburg, Mississipi, Gathright attended Bonnabel High School in Kenner, Louisiana. There, he excelled as a high school hitter, combining a fleet foot with an exceptional contact bat.^ Noticing such tremendous tools, the Tampa Bay Devil Rays selected him in the 32nd round of the 2001 amateur entry draft. Upon signing in August, Gathright waited one year before entering Class-A Charleston, where he hit .264/.360/.269 in 208 at-bats. The following season, he combined a .324/.406/.359 and .376/.419/.388 at Class A+ Bakersfield and Class AA Orlando. In Bakersfield, Gathright solidified himself as one of the best runners in the Minor Leagues, stealing 57 bases in 70 attempts. Although he had never hit one career home run, he batted for tremendous contact, hitting .326 and .341 for two levels in 2004. He was revered as one of the hottest prospects in the low minors, and won the Baseball America 2nd team Minor League All-Star award, California League Rookie of the Year award, and the California League All Star award. The following season, he was promoted to the parent club - Tampa Bay.
(Editor's Note: A hat-tip to neroyalsfan11 over at Royals Nation for pointing out that Gathright was originally a track runner, and only played baseball his senior year in high school.)
By 2004, Gathright had begun to solidify himself as a precursor to the 1970's and 1980's era leadoff men extraordinaires, from Otis Nixon to Brett Butler. Joey split the 2005 season between Class AAA Durham and Tampa Bay. Throughout the Minor Leagues, Gathright had worked the count often and got on base at an excellent clip. However, initially, his high-OBP game did not translate to the big league level, with merely a +40 and +66 BA/OBP split the first two short seasons in St. Petersburg.

On a summer evening in 2002, the fleetfooted Joey Gathright decided to jump over two vehicles in a parking lot.
After a lowly 2006 campaign with Durham and Tampa Bay, Gathright, along with infielder Fernando Cortez, was sent to our Boys in Blue for 22-year old left handed pitcher J.P. Howell, always considered long on potential but, at the time, severely short on outcome. It was a controversial trade at the time on behalf of Dayton Moore, as it received mixed - and emotional - results on both the Devil Rays blogosphere and the Royals blogosphere. Dayton Moore defended the move, citing defensive need in a spacious ballpark:
"We've got to make sure that we've got outstanding defense in this ballpark," Moore said of the decision to trade a pitching prospect for speed and defense. "With DeJesus (David, who moved from center to left) and Gathright we certainly have some guys who can track the ball. We've got to be athletic in this ballpark."
That season, Gathright spent 229 at-bats playing mostly center field in Kansas City, forcing DeJesus over to an unfamiliar left field. Gathright delivered almost instantly in Kansas City with the potential he demonstrated in the Minor Leagues, connecting for a .262/.332/.328 line in 79 games. However, in 2007, after an epic Spring Training battle with fellow on-the-cusp outfielders Shane Costa and Justin Huber, Gathright was confined to the AAA level for at least a small part of one more season. Gathright performed brilliantly in Omaha early in the season, earning a permanent callup after outfielder Reggie Sanders was sidelined for the second time. Gathright performed promising in Kansas City, drilling 70 hits in 74 games.
However, the analysis of Joey Gathright must delve deeper than simply the numbers at first glance. Consider these numbers, referenced by the always informative mtroyals over on RoyalBoard.com.
Tampa Bay:
Kansas City:
- 6 SB, 1 CS = 85%
- 20 SB, 5 CS = 80%
- 12 SB, 3 CS = 80%
- 10 SB, 6 CS = 62%
- 9 SB, 8 CS = 52%
Gathright has not exactly performed well on the basepaths in Kansas City. Could the difference merely be coincidence, sending him on the incorrect counts, the natural grass at Kauffman Stadium, or simply having the cannon-armed Ivan Rodriguez in the same division? That is a question that remains to be seen. One thing is for sure: In order to maintain a position somewhere in the Royals lineup, Gathright must begin to translate his exceptional raw speed into baseball speed. This would not only include stealing bases more often and more effectively, but covering ground and getting better reads and reactions on fly balls.
According to the Topeka Capital-Journal, Gathright's Tampa Bay biography stated that he runs from home plate to first base in 3.3 seconds on a bunt. Also, he has been timed at an amazing 6.1 seconds in a 60-yard dash.
Because the corner outfield positions demand such power, Gathright would ideally be better suited as strictly a center fielder. Unfortunately, in our situation, the talented - yet not exactly power-talented - David DeJesus will occupy that role for the forseeable future (barring, of course, a trade). Gathright's singles-hitting isn't sufficient for a left fielder, and given the team's lack of doubles and home run power (they finished dead last in total bases and slugging percentage), his presence in the lineup takes away from something a player like Justin Huber or Chris Lubanski could possibly grant us. Power.
ASSETS:
GS/G: 49/81
AB: 221
H: 59
BA: .267
OBP: .343
SLG: .317
1B: 50
2B: 7
3B: 2
HR: 0
RBI: 21
R: 26
BB: 17
K: 34
SB: 15
CS: 9
OPS+: 78
On-field performance:
Tremendous dropoff from 2007: 10%
Slight dropoff from 2007: 35%
Repeats 2007 form: 40%
True breakthrough season (.300/.400/.350): 15%
Injury contingency:
Injured for 15 days or more: 5%
Whereabouts:
Chances traded/released before Opening Day: 20%
Chances traded at 2008 Trade Deadline: 15%
Job allocation:
Starting outfielder: 15%
Platoon role: 5%
Bench/reserve role: 55%
Season split between K.C. and Omaha: 25%
To be honest, I think Gathright's maximum potential is still that of a capable vintage-style leadoff man. However, with David DeJesus present, that team is currently not the Royals. The Royals could best implement him as a fourth outfielder. What is most vital to his 2008 campaign is whether he can translate his running abilities into stolen bases. Then, Gathright could be used as a pinch runner. In fact, I predict that Gathright will translate his skills slightly more effectively this season, improving his instincts and range in left field (and occasionally center) and stealing a few bases in close and late pinch-running roles. Offensively, he could still forseeably become a true leadoff man. His OBP and contact skills rival that of DeJesus and Mark Teahen, although those two are slightly more proven commodities.
From a fans' perspective, Gathright is an energetic presence and a fun player to watch. Every team could use a sparkplug such as Joey, in some role, somewhere.
0 recs |
24
comments
Comments
I really don't think he'll get worse
I don't expect greatness from Gathright. I don't think he'll ever be good enough to be a regular corner OFer. I think his defensive deficiencies make it unlikely that he'll ever be good enough to be a starter CFer either. But I do expect him to be a pretty good 4th OFer and one should expect at least a little improvement in 2008.
OBP: .375
SLG: .360
by NYRoyal on Jan 27, 2008 6:44 PM EST 0 recs
RoyalsNation, I have a question
by NYRoyal on Jan 27, 2008 7:05 PM EST 0 recs
I must have missed this
by Royals Nation on
Jan 29, 2008 10:12 AM EST
up
0 recs
To elaborate even further
I'm a risktaker. Sometimes, I think it might pay off in the end.
by Royals Nation on
Jan 29, 2008 10:15 AM EST
up
0 recs
I like Joey
He's a nice guy to have as a bench player, but he probably shouldn't be getting more than 300 PAs a year.
I'd expect a .280/.350/.320 from Joey.
by RoyalsRetro on Jan 27, 2008 10:41 PM EST 0 recs
Its kind of sad
by dman126 on Jan 28, 2008 11:25 AM EST 0 recs
Projections and OPS
OPS is good as a quick reference for a player's overall offensive prowess, but it actually undervalues OBP slightly in comparison to SLG (at least, according to Rob Neyer). So Gathright's OPS is more productive than your average 700ish OPS, especially if he returns to form on the basepaths. Talented enough to start for a lot of teams, he should probably be a fourth outfielder for the Royals. I think he'll be one of the best fourth outfielders in baseball.
by Melchizedek on Jan 28, 2008 8:43 PM EST 0 recs
Like Joey
by fergusques on Jan 29, 2008 12:05 AM EST 0 recs
probably a dead horse, but
dejesus for a-rod, straight up. we'll even let a-rod play short.
by Gordon Roy on Jan 29, 2008 8:30 AM EST 0 recs
He has trade value
But I am uncomfortable having Gathright start every day. He's a huge drop off offensively from DJ.
by RoyalsRetro on
Jan 29, 2008 9:37 AM EST
up
0 recs
Callaspo
by dman126 on
Jan 29, 2008 11:31 AM EST
up
0 recs
DDJ has tailed off
I can see the Royals trading him at mid-season however
by royalsreview on
Jan 29, 2008 1:09 PM EST
up
0 recs
Is one bad season a "tail off"?
And I don't know why people call him "bland" or "boring." What does that mean? He's an above average major league CFer with multiple plus skills. And he's cheap. Players who are above average for their position with cheap long-term contracts are quite valuable, both to the Royals and on the trade market.
by NYRoyal on
Jan 29, 2008 2:05 PM EST
up
0 recs
I agree
by RoyalsRetro on
Jan 29, 2008 3:02 PM EST
up
0 recs
good point
by LeoBloom on
Jan 29, 2008 4:13 PM EST
up
0 recs
yea...
I remember last season when the PECOTAs came out and it basically pegged DDJ as already having topped out (which looks accurate). That was a bit of a blow.
But anyway, no, he's not actually a bad player or anything. Its just no one sees promise anymore, rightly or wrongly.
by royalsreview on
Jan 29, 2008 4:20 PM EST
up
0 recs
Trading DeJesus
Also, I think we have to get away from the mindset of having one player to fill each niche on the team. Depth is good. If we trade Teahen or DeJesus, then as soon as someone gets injured, Shane Costa is getting PAs in Kansas City. That's fine when you're in rebuilding mode, but now that we're turning the corner and actually trying to field a good Major League team, it isn't acceptable. We actually need four good outfielders, because I don't want to see Costa vs. Sabathia in a pennant race. So unless Lubanski starts tearing Omaha apart with his bare hands (and a bat) or something, there's no burning need to trade away an outfielder.
by Melchizedek on
Jan 29, 2008 3:46 PM EST
up
0 recs
Much worse, in my opinion
Costa .260/.295/.350
Joey .285/.370/.350
Given that OBP is more important than SLG, Joey's line is much better than Costa's.
by NYRoyal on
Jan 29, 2008 4:55 PM EST
up
0 recs
The question is
by Melchizedek on
Jan 29, 2008 9:30 PM EST
up
0 recs
the equation has to be
if Gathright can truly hit .300/.400/.350, i might take those odds
by LeoBloom on Jan 29, 2008 4:14 PM EST 0 recs
If...
Those are both big ifs though.
by DC Royal on Jan 29, 2008 4:33 PM EST 0 recs
The big problem with Gathright in CF
by NYRoyal on Jan 29, 2008 4:58 PM EST 0 recs
Gator's Parabolic Routes
by philofthenorth on
Jan 30, 2008 4:01 PM EST
up
0 recs








